Classic Sauces
Spaghetti with a Giant Meatball
16.75
Our #1 seller since 1959: our giant homemade meatball over a mound of spaghetti covered with our authentic old world meat sauce.
Gnocchi with a Giant Meatball
18.25
Potato dumplings covered with our classic meat sauce and topped with a giant homemade meatball — a classic Mary’s recipe.
Penne with Italian Sausage
16.95
Mild Italian sausage sautéed with mushrooms, red onions, garlic and Italian parsley, mixed with penne pasta and homemade marinara sauce.
Creamy
Chicken Parmigiana
18.25
Lightly breaded chicken breast smothered in homemade marinara sauce and melted provolone, served on a bed of creamy fettuccine Alfredo.
Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
18.25
Sliced chicken breast smothered in our creamy Alfredo sauce with fresh mushrooms and red onions on a bed of fettuccine.
Stuffed + Layered
Meat or Cheese Ravioli
17.25
Mary’s original recipe of hearty meat or cheese ravioli generously topped with our classic meat sauce or homemade marinara.
Mary’s Classic Lasagna
17.25
Mild Italian sausage, salami, pepperoni, spinach, mozzarella and ricotta, layered on lasagna noodles topped with our classic homemade meat sauce and melted mozzarella.
Non-Pasta Plates
“He & She”
12.75
Named after a beauty salon near the Original Shack: two giant meatballs smothered in our classic meat sauce and topped with melted mozzarella.
Protein Plate
12.75
Your choice of a grilled chicken breast or a 1/3 lb beef* patty topped with your choice of sautéed mushrooms and garlic or sautéed vegetables.
NEW Peggy’s Meatloaf
16.95
*Served a la carte! Add a cup of soup, side salad, or fries for $4.25*
A generous portion of Peggy’s homemade signature meatloaf is served with mashed potatoes and our own veggie sauté in lemon butter.
*Served a la carte! Add a cup of soup, side salad, or fries for $4.25*
